A Schmidt for a Penny in Oak Ridge

Today’s tale will be about a bride and groom who were married on this date 130 years ago. The bride had her beginning as a Lutheran, but the groom was not. I will begin with the bride.

Marie Caroline Friedricka Christiana Schmidt was born on June 8, 1872. She was mostly called Carrie during her lifetime, and even has that name on her gravestone, so that is the name I will use for her in this post. Carrie was the daughter of Charles and Louisa (Jungblut – Youngblood) Schmidt. Carrie has her baptism record in the books of Trinity Lutheran Church in Friedheim. We can view that baptism record below.

Carrie Schmidt baptism record – Trinity, Friedheim, MO

Carrie’s father died in a construction accident when she was just one year old. Then, her mother married William Riehn. That explains what we see when we view Carrie’s entry in the 1880 census. Carrie was 7 years old and called a stepdaughter. Her stepfather was a farmer in the Whitewater Township of Cape Girardeau County. The Schmidt name is spelled as Smith in this entry.

1880 census – Whitewater Township, Cape Girardeau County, MO

Because we cannot view the 1890 census, that would be the only entry in which we find Carrie prior to her marriage. So, we will now take a look at the man who would become her husband. His name was Charles Cullen Penny, who was born on August 28, 1873. He was born near Oak Ridge, one of a dozen children of John and Susanah (Drum) Penny. Here are photos of Charles’s parents.

I discovered that a daughter of today’s couple had a certificate acknowledging her membership in the Daughters of the American Revolution. That means she could trace her lineage back to someone who fought in the Revolutionary War. Both of Charles’s parents had ancestors who were already living in America prior to that war. Much of their ancestor’s lives were spent in the state of North Carolina.

I am not certain where Charles was baptized, but we know that he was a member of Oak Ridge United Methodist Church during his life. That congregation was established in 1873, so I think it is possible that Charles was one of the first children baptized there. Charles is found in the 1880 census at the age of 6. His father was a farmer in the Apple Creek Township.

1880 census – Apple Creek Township, MO

I did find Charles in a list of members of Old Salem Methodist Church which was located in Millersville. That record seems to indicate that he was not baptized there, but became a member at one time. I did notice in those records there were also some Riehn’s and Smith’s.

Charles Penny married Carrie Schmidt on November 22, 1896. According to their Missouri marriage record below, they were married by a minister in Oak Ridge, so I think they were married at the Oak Ridge United Methodist Church or the Old Salem Methodist Church. Once again, Carrie’s surname is given as Smith.

Penny/Schmidt marriage license

In the 1900 census, we see that the Penny’s had yet to have any children. Charles was called a livery stableman in the Apple Creek Township.

1900 census – Apple Creek Township, MO

The Penny’s only child was a girl by the name of Willie Lucille born in 1902. When the 1910 census was taken, the Penny household consisted of Charles, Carrie, and Willie. Charles had a livery business. Right above their household on that census page, you will see the household of John Bowers, who was a harness maker. I figure it was very convenient for a harness maker to be near a livery man. In addition, above the Bowers family, you will see that of Lewis Schmidt, who was Carrie’s older brother. Lewis’s story was told in the post, Lewis and Carrie – Oak Ridge Schmidt’s.

1910 census – Apple Creek Township, MO

Charles had his World War I draft registration completed in 1918. He is given an Oak Ridge address and called a farmer on this document.

Charles Penny – WWI draft registration

In the 1920 census, Charles and Carrie were in their 40’s. Charles is called a farmer and chauffeur. In old days, a chauffeur was someone who did some sort of driving. In the business column, it uses the term “service car”.

1920 census – Apple Creek Township, MO

The 1930 census shows the same trio of Penny’s. This time Charles was just called a farmer and said to be living in Oak Ridge. Their daughter, Willie, was a public school teacher.

1930 census – Oak Ridge, MO

1930 was also the year when Cape Girardeau County had plat maps produced. In the imabe below, you can see the the land owned by C.C. Penny located not far from Oak Ridge. To the east of them, you will also see the land farmed by L.W. Schmidt, Carrie’s brother.

C.C. Penny land map – 1930

At some point, Charles had this photo taken. I was not able to find a picture of Carrie.

Charles Penny

The 1940 census shows Charles and Carrie with an empty nest. Charles, at the age of 66, was still called a farmer.

1940 census – Oak Ridge, MO

The last census we can view is the one taken in 1950. This time, Charles was said to be caring for livestock on a farm.

1950 census – Oak Ridge, MO

Charles Penny died in 1953 at the age of 79. His death certificate below says he died of melanoma.

Charles Penny death certificate

We can read an obituary for Charles that was printed in the Cash Book Journal.

Charles Penny – CBJ obituary

Carrie Penny did not die until 1971 at the age of 98. According to her death certificate below, it looks like she was still living in her home when she died.

Carrie Penny death certificate

Charles and Carrie Penny are each buried in the Cape County Memorial Park in Cape Girardeau.

I noticed that several men in the Penny extended family have the middle name of Cullen. I think that is because Charles’s grandfather was named Cullin Penny. In fact, Cullen’s gravestone is found in the York Chapel Cemetery near Longtown.

Cullen Penny gravestone – York Chapel, Longtown, MO

It looks like it was Cullen Penny who moved his family from North Carolina to Missouri back in the 1830’s. Perhaps because he was the pioneer Missouri Penny that future boys in the Penny family carried the Cullen name.


Leave a Reply