Schieferdecker Splits – Then Returns

The birthday boy today is Rev. George Albert Schieferdecker.  He was born on March 12, 1815 in Germany and was one of the original members of the Gesellschaft.  He came to America aboard the Copernicus.  On the passenger list, he is called a Candidate of Theology.


Copernicus Passenger List p1 Buenger Schieferdecker
Copernicus – passenger list

In the early years, George served in teaching responsibilities in Perry County and St. Louis.  Then in 1841, he was ordained and started a church in Monroe County, Illinois.  I believe that congregation eventually became Holy Cross Lutheran Church in Wartburg.  He is also credited with organizing Trinity Lutheran Church in Millstadt, Illinois.  Here is what those churches look like today.  Holy Cross is on the left; Trinity on the right.

On June 15, 1845, Rev. Schieferdecker returned to Perry County to marry Marie Pauline Gruber, the daughter Rev. Carl Gruber, who was the first pastor of Grace Lutheran Church in Uniontown.  When this marriage took place, that town was still called Paitzdorf.

Rev. Georg Schieferdecker
Rev. Georg Albert Schieferdecker

When Rev. Gotthold Loeber died in Altenburg in 1849, Trinity decided to call Rev. Schieferdecker as their pastor.  He accepted the call, but was not able to get to Altenburg until 1850.  In 1854, the Western District of the Synod was formed, and Rev. Schieferdecker became its first President.

Some trouble started brewing in 1856, and Rev. Schieferdecker called for the Western District to study the doctrine of millenialism, which involves the interpretation of Revelation 20 and the end times.  Rev. Schieferdecker, as it turns out, was in support of a different interpretation than that of the Western District and the Synod.  After considerable efforts by the Synod to get Rev. Schieferdecker to change his views on millenialism.  He refused, and he was removed from the Synod in 1857.  About two-thirds of Trinity’s members agreed with the Synod’s decision.  However, Rev. Schieferdecker gathered the other one-third of the congregation and started a new church in Altenburg which was named Immanuel.  This new church became a member of the Iowa Synod.

Immanuel Church Florence Lorenz

Rev. Schieferdecker remained in Altenburg until 1866, when he left to become a pastor in Clarion, Illinois.  After discussions with others in the Missouri Synod, Rev. Schieferdecker recanted his views on millinialism and rejoined the Missouri Synod.  In 1876, he was serving two congregations in Hillsdale and Coldwater, Michigan.  He apparently did not stay there long.  In 1877, he became pastor of Neu Gehlenbeck in Madison County, Illinois.  That church would later take on the name St. Paul’s Lutheran Church in Hamel, Illinois.  Here is a photo of their old church taken sometime near the end of the 1800’s.

St. Paul Hamel

It was here that Rev. Schieferdecker died in 1891.  His wife, Marie, died in 1895.  They are both buried in the St. Paul Cemetery in Hamel.

St. Paul Hamel Cemetery

You can see a reference to New Gehlenbeck on the sign at this cemetery.  I would love to know the origin of this term.

Rev. Schieferdecker left the Synod for a while, but eventually returned.  The same can be said for the congregation he started in Altenburg.  On May 26, 1988, after the congregation voted to become a part of the LCMS, Immanuel was officially accepted back.




2 thoughts on “Schieferdecker Splits – Then Returns

  1. In line one, his first name is given as ‘George’. Under the caption, it is given as “Georg’. At most genealogical websites, it is shown as ‘Georg’, so I assume that is the correct spelling.


  2. If you are referring to the term “New Gehlenbeck” on the cemetery sign, it refers to the original Lutheran Church in Gehlenbeck, Germany from which many of the founding families in the area (Worden, Hamel, etc.) immigrated from, near Hannover.


Leave a Reply

Fill in your details below or click an icon to log in: Logo

You are commenting using your account. Log Out /  Change )

Twitter picture

You are commenting using your Twitter account. Log Out /  Change )

Facebook photo

You are commenting using your Facebook account. Log Out /  Change )

Connecting to %s