First Burial

I wrote yesterday that I do not often use an early death as the starting point for a blog post.  Now I am about to write my second post in a row that starts that way.  What attracted me to an early death today is the likelihood that this death led to the first burial in a new cemetery.  The baby who died was Luella Petzoldt, and the new cemetery was the one operated by the relatively new congregation in Wittenberg, St. Paul’s Lutheran Church.

When the German Lutherans arrived in East Perry County in 1839,  one of the seven settlements established was Wittenberg.  However, this community located on the banks of the Mississippi River and destined to be the center of commerce for this new German colony, was not “assigned” a pastor to be their spiritual leader.  Instead, other nearby pastors would travel to Wittenberg regularly to conduct worship services in that town.  A church building was even built for that community, but for quite a long time, the people that worshiped there were not an official congregation and did not have their own pastor.  That building was also used as a school during the week.

Wittenberg First Church and School

For the most part, the Wittenberg community of believers became an extension of Trinity Lutheran Church in Altenburg.  Their church records were included in the Trinity church books, and when people died from that group, they were usually buried in the Trinity Lutheran Cemetery.

That all changed in 1903.  On Sunday, May 3, 1903, the congregation in Wittenberg became an official church called St. Paul’s Lutheran Church and held their first worship service with their first pastor, Rev. Frank Albrecht.  The first chapter of my book, Wittenberg ’03: The Coming of a Church, describes events which may have taken place on that day.  Below is a photo of some of the early pastors and teachers of St. Paul’s.

Early pastors and teachers St. Paul's Wittenberg MO

Also included in that book, which is historical fiction, is the discussion in the early days of that church concerning their need for a cemetery of their own.  I know the book is fiction, but I tried to base that discussion on the facts that I know to be true.  I intend to talk about those facts today, and the death of Luella Petzoldt is one of those facts.

Luella Petzoldt was born on November 10, 1903.  Her parents were Otto and Martha (Mueller) Petzoldt.  Below are photos of her parents.


Luella was also a granddaughter of Joseph and Mathilda (Buenger) Mueller.  Joseph operated a general store in Wittenberg that has been mentioned in several previous posts on this blog.  Joseph and “Tillie” are shown in photos below.


Luella was the 8th baptism at St. Paul’s.  Her baptism record is shown below.

Luella Petzoldt baptism record St. Paul's Wittenberg MO
Luella Petzoldt baptism record – St. Paul’s, Wittenberg, MO

I purposely included the 9th and 10th baptism records also.  Philipp (#9) was the son of Frank and Johanna Albrecht.  In other words, he was the pastor’s kid.  The #10 baptism was Alma Sarah Boehme.  She will be mentioned later.

Now let’s take a look at the first death records for St. Paul’s.  The image below shows the first 5 deaths in their church books.

St. Paul's Wittenberg First 5 death records

Heinrich Theiss is the first death recorded.  That death was one of two that occurred in 1903, the first year of St. Paul’s existence.  You can find Heinrich’s gravestone in the Trinity Lutheran Cemetery in Altenburg.

Heinrich Theiss gravestone Trinity Altenburg MO
Heinrich Theiss gravestone – Trinity, Altenburg, MO

The second death in 1903 was Amanda Winter.  I could not find her gravestone in either Trinity’s or St. Paul’s Cemetery.  I speculated in Wittenberg ’03 that she was buried at her parents’ farmplace.  But again, that is fiction.

That leads us to the death of Luella Petzoldt which took place on today’s date in 1904.  I will likely include this event in Wittenberg ’04 which I am currently writing.  We do find Luella’s gravestone in the St. Paul’s Cemetery, and I think she is the first burial there.

Luella Petzoldt gravestone St. Paul's Wittenberg MO
Luella Petzoldt gravestone – St. Paul’s, Wittenberg, MO

For some reason, this gravestone is not included on, but we do have the photo shown above in our research library.

The death record right after Luella’s was that of Alma Sarah Boehme.  She was born two weeks after Luella and died one week after Luella.  Below is her gravestone in the St. Paul’s Lutheran Cemetery.

Alma Sarah Boehme gravestone St. Paul's Wittenberg MO
Alma Sarah Boehme gravestone – St. Paul’s, Wittenberg, MO

Two days after Alma’s death, there was yet another death of a child.  His name was Lambert Raymond Bundenthal.  This was a very unusual death.  Lambert was the son of Rev. Theodore and Concordia (Weinhold) Bundenthal.  Rev. Bundenthal was a pastor near Sedalia, Missouri and his family must have been in Wittenberg for the wedding of Concordia’s sister, Lydia.  Lydia married Otto Lueders (both main characters in my book) on July 10, 1904.  Apparently, while in Wittenberg, their 10 month old son died of cholera.  The death record is in the St. Paul’s church books, but I could not locate a grave site for Lambert in their cemetery.  I still haven’t decided if I will include this sad story in my next book.

Another fact we know about the St. Paul’s Lutheran Cemetery is that this congregation managed to get this piece of property from a man by the name of Charles Swan.  Charles and his wife, who was a Palisch, were not members of St. Paul’s.  They were members of Immanuel Lutheran Church in Altenburg.  But he must have been willing to sell a small portion of his land to this congregation for the purpose of establishing a new cemetery.  Many churches had cemeteries right outside their sanctuaries, but St. Paul’s did not have enough land around their church, so they needed to acquire some land elsewhere.  We see the Swan land in the 1915 map shown here.

Charles Swan land map 1915
Charles Swan land map – 1915

The St. Paul’s Cemetery can be found right next to the road shown adjacent to the Swan property.   Here is a photo of the cemetery.

St. Paul's Lutheran Cemetery Wittenberg MO
St. Paul’s Lutheran Cemetery – Wittenberg, MO

I just want to say a few more things about the Petzoldt family.  Luella never got old enough to know this, but she had three siblings.  Two were the same age, but were not twins.  That is because a girl by the name of Loretta was adopted.  The oldest son, Waldemar, became a Lutheran pastor.  He served at Mount Hulda Lutheran Church near Cole Camp, Missouri.  This is what his church must have looked like when he was there.

Mt. Hulda Lutheran Church Benton County MO
Mount Hulda Lutheran Church

Waldemar then spent the rest of his career across the Mississippi River from Wittenberg at Christ Lutheran Church in Jacob, Illinois.  He was there from 1948-1973.

Waldemar Petzoldt


Another brother was Lanson Petzoldt.  I have been told that he was a mail carrier most of his life in the Wittenberg/Altenburg vicinity.  I found this great photo of Lanson standing in front of Tower Rock.

Lanson Petzoldt
Lanson Petzoldt

One final thing.  The St.Paul’s Lutheran Cemetery has been under water for a long time now.  It has been reported that the present flooding we are experiencing is now a record-setting flood, not in height, but in its duration.  I do know this.  It is still going to be a while before anyone has to go down there and mow the grass.



5 thoughts on “First Burial

  1. David Wurdeman, thanks for your kind words about my grandfather, Reverend Waldemar Petzoldt. My dad Herb and aunt Delores were born in Mount Hulda, but by the time I came along Grandpa had been pastor in Jacob IL for several years, In fact, his church there had planned to honor him for his 45 years at the church on the day Grandpa unexpectedly died. That was the ONLY Sunday Grandpa ever missed preaching due to illness.


  2. My grandfather was Waldemar Petzoldt. I’m starting to work on a family tree now and was confused about what looked like two sisters, Loretta and Louella, born the same year but not twins. Thanks for clearing that up. My grandmother, Ruth Martha (Fiehler) Petzoldt, lived to be 102 whereas Grandpa died pretty suddenly of leukemia in 1973. I have some photos, if you’d be interested. My father was Waldemar and Ruth’s son Herbert Petzoldt, who died in 1978 of melanoma — Herb was a terrific dad and all children adored him. Waldemar and Ruth’s daughter, Delores, lives in Bethalto IL and is doing well.


  3. My parents ( Clarence Wurdeman and Oletha Ehlers Wurdeman) attended MT. Hulda Lutheran church their entire lives. Baptized and confirmed there. They always spoke highly of Rev. Petzoldt. As well as my aunt’s who knew the Petzoldt family. Thanks for the article.

    Liked by 1 person

Leave a Reply

Fill in your details below or click an icon to log in: Logo

You are commenting using your account. Log Out /  Change )

Facebook photo

You are commenting using your Facebook account. Log Out /  Change )

Connecting to %s